Review: Replacement by Jordan Rivet



Replacement follows the story of Jane, a forgotten clone in a factory-like facility where most of the others are part of larger "batches" who have been cloned/designed to take on specific roles in society. Jane is yearning and searching for "batchmates" and for answers. She wants to know who "sponsored" her to be cloned in the first place and why. To connect with her identity. 

She thinks she might get answers when she is sent to replace/pretend to be Janie, one of these batchmates she has been yearning to find, but she find a whole bunch more questions! 

This was a great, well-written read that had mystery and explored the ethical issues that arise from cloning in an entertaining way. Since Jane is a teenager there was a bit of school life/teen relationship stuff that was written in a realistic way that didn't overpower other aspects of the story. It all served to move the story along and help explore Jane's struggles, because on the one hand she has to convince everyone she's Janie, but on the other hand, she's starting to actually get emotionally connected to different aspects of Janie's life and that's making it harder for her to just pretend. Great storytelling overall. 

I also really enjoyed the other dimensions to the story beyond her trying to fit into Janie's place. She does her own exploring and digging and uncovers a lot of information and also makes some allies and enemies along the way. There's spying, implant technology, secret factories and shady characters. 

One aspect of the ending, and how some things ended up being done by only one character where I expected it to be a larger issue, kind of annoyed me, but it did allow this first book in a series to have its own ending, so I guess it was good in a way. 

Overall. a great read and it sets the bar high for the other SPSFC Quarterfinalists that I will be reading as part of my judging for team Peripheral Prospectors. This review is only my own opinion on the book. The decision will be made on whether to move the book forward in the competition or not as a team once we've all read the books! 

Comments

  1. Hiking ReaderNovember 27, 2023 at 5:06 AM

    This one sounds really interesting. I'm looking forward to getting to this one as we try to narrow down which book(s) move on!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. NoorNovember 27, 2023 at 12:58 PM

      Yeah, it's pretty good! I can't wait to hear what you think of it! :)

      Delete
  2. NicoleNovember 28, 2023 at 1:31 PM

    I really enjoyed the part of this that I sampled for the slush pile reading process! I'm looking forward to finishing it soon. Thanks for the review!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. NoorNovember 29, 2023 at 1:10 PM

      :) I look forward to being able to discuss it without having to avoid spoilers when you're done!

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Review: Time to Play (Apocalypse Parenting Book 1) by Erin Ampersand

Image
Time to Play (Apocalypse Parenting Book 1) is a LitRPG book about a mother thrust into an apocalyptic game-like situation with her three kids. One minute she's worrying about driving them to their sports lessons and the next minute the electricity stops working and an announcement informs her - and everyone else - that earth has just become the site of some alien game-show and they're now the unwilling contestants in this game. It's such an excellent premise with some great characterization that grounds it and makes it very, very real. I flew through this book in about two days because it was such a page-turner. One of the main draws that kept me turning the pages is the main character Meghan's realistic struggles and reactions as a mother of three. In a way, it's a book where monsters suddenly spawn and the characters can collect points and have to figure out how to survive, but it's also really just a book about the struggles of parenting, because it's not...
Read more

Review: The Firetouched (Firebrand Book 2) by D. E. Olesen

Image
Firebrand Book 2: The Fire-Touched is an excellent follow-up to the first book. It continues the story of Martel as he completes his first year at the Lyceum, hoping that by the end of it, he'll finally pass the novice stage and become an acolyte like the others his age. As this is the second book Martel has become more comfortable at the school and with the surrounding city and I also enjoyed sinking comfortably back into this well-built world with Martel. I enjoyed this second installment almost more than I did the first.  Martel's characterization is consistent with the first one, and he continues to get himself into tough situations and put himself into danger to help others, but by now he has his feet under him a bit more and is better able to handle the situations he gets into - and pick out friends from foes from people who are trying to use him. There's lots of great character work not only for Martel, but also some of the side-characters.  In terms of his magical e...
Read more

Review: Outlaw Mage by K. S. Villoso

Image
  Outlaw Mage by K. S. Villoso follows the adventures of Rosha, a young woman with the ability to do magic living in an empire where she's an outsider. This book is full of what I love most about Villoso's work: those raw, deep observations about what it feels like to be an outsider trying to find or make a place for yourself in a society that doesn't have a place for you except on the sidelines. There's a fast-paced, action-packed story full of magic and secrets and even empire politics, but those few, scattered thoughts where Rosha is trying to come to terms with the way others see her, the way the empire treats her and her family, those are what raise this book above others of its kind and convince me that K. S. Villoso will one day be considered one of the greatest writers of this generation.  "The Empire of Dageis, mighty conqueror, the bastion of civilizations, envy of the world. And yet its people cannot grasp how a mere Gorenten child could make a pebble fl...
Read more